St Michaels Church of England Academy

About St Michaels Church of England Academy

St Michaels Church of England Academy in Sefton received an Inadequate rating from Ofsted following its graded inspection in June 2024, a significant downgrade from its previous Requires improvement judgement in 2022. The inspection report, published in September 2024, paints a stark picture: leadership and management, along with quality of education, were both rated Inadequate, while behaviour and attitudes, personal development, and sixth-form provision were judged as Requires improvement. This places the school in a challenging position, particularly given that none of the 20 secondary schools in Sefton currently hold an Outstanding rating. The most telling academic metric available is the local authority's average Progress 8 score of -0.59, which provides a benchmark for how pupils at schools in the area typically perform relative to the national average. For parents considering St Michaels, this data signals that the school is operating well below the standard expected, and the leadership under headteacher Roy Bellmon faces a considerable task in addressing the inspectors' concerns.

The school's academic outcomes are best understood through the lens of its Ofsted breakdown, as specific exam results like Progress 8 or Attainment 8 scores are not provided in the data. The Inadequate rating for quality of education suggests that teaching, curriculum, and assessment are not meeting the required standard, while the Requires improvement judgement for sixth-form provision indicates that post-16 education also needs work. Compared with the Sefton local authority average Progress 8 score of -0.59, which already sits below the national average of zero, St Michaels appears to be struggling more acutely than many of its peers. For context, the top-performing school in the area, Formby High School, has a ranking score of 0.43, while Range High School and Meols Cop High School sit at -0.15 and -0.17 respectively. This gap highlights the scale of the challenge at St Michaels, where the school's overall effectiveness has declined rather than improved over successive inspections.

Despite its academic difficulties, St Michaels offers a broad range of facilities that could support a turnaround, including a swimming pool, theatre, chapel, science labs, astro turf, and a sixth-form centre. The school runs a wide variety of clubs and sports, from martial arts and rugby to Model UN and orchestra, which could help engage pupils beyond the classroom. There is no data on SEND provisions, admissions oversubscription, or parental views, so it is unclear how the school is perceived locally or how selective it is. This school is likely to suit families who are committed to being part of a recovery journey and who value a Church of England ethos and a full extracurricular programme, but who are prepared for the reality that academic standards and behaviour management are currently areas of serious concern. Given the Inadequate rating, parents should expect close monitoring from the Department for Education and potential structural changes ahead.

Key Details

Frequently Asked Questions About St Michaels Church of England Academy

Helpful Guides for Parents