St Aelred's Catholic Primary School - a Catholic Voluntary Academy
85%
Capacity
178
Pupils
2.1x
Demand
About St Aelred's Catholic Primary School - a Catholic Voluntary Academy
St Aelred's Catholic Primary School sits at the bottom of York's primary school rankings, a position that stands in stark contrast to the local authority average. With just 32% of pupils reaching the expected standard in reading, writing and maths combined at Key Stage 2, the school is well below the York average of 62%. This places it 47th out of 47 primary schools in the local authority, in the bottom 50% nationally. The school's ranking score of 32 is a long way from the top-performing local primaries, such as Knavesmire Primary School with a score of 92. However, the school serves a community with a high level of disadvantage: 32.6% of pupils are eligible for free school meals, more than double the national average. This context matters when interpreting the headline figures, and the school's Good Ofsted rating suggests that leadership is aware of the challenges and is working within them.
Looking more closely at the 2023/24 Key Stage 2 results, the picture is mixed across individual subjects. In writing, 58% of pupils met the expected standard, which is the strongest result of the three core subjects, while 13% reached the higher standard. Reading and maths both saw 45% and 39% of pupils at the expected level respectively, with average scaled scores of 99 in each. Only 3% of pupils achieved the higher standard across all three subjects. The school does not publish progress scores for reading, writing or maths, so it is difficult to say how much value the school adds relative to pupils' starting points. In its most recent Ofsted inspection in January 2024, inspectors rated the school Good across all five categories: quality of education, behaviour and attitudes, personal development, leadership and management, and early years provision. This was a consistent performance compared with its previous inspection in 2012, which also rated overall effectiveness as Good.
St Aelred's is a small Catholic primary school with 178 pupils on roll, operating below its capacity of 210. It offers nursery provision for children from age three, and the school day runs through to Year 6. The school is oversubscribed for Reception places in 2025/26, with 30 applications for 14 places and 12 first-preference offers made, giving an oversubscription ratio of 2.14. Facilities include a sports hall, playing fields, a library, a sensory room, a chapel and a Forest School area. There is a good range of clubs, including gardening, eco club, science club, drama and coding, plus sports such as gymnastics, tennis, cross country and netball. The school has identified SEND provisions for specific learning difficulties, moderate learning difficulties, social, emotional and mental health needs, speech, language and communication needs, and autistic spectrum disorder. This is a school that will suit families who value a Catholic ethos and a small, community-focused setting, but parents should be aware that academic outcomes are significantly below the local average.
Key Details
| School Type | Primary (State) |
| Age Range | 3 to 11 years |
| Gender | Mixed |
| Religious Character | Roman Catholic |
| Address | Fifth Avenue, York, York, YO31 0QQ |
| Headteacher | Claire Hughes |
| Local Authority | York |
| Number of Pupils | 178 |
| Free School Meals (FSM) | 32.6% |
| School Capacity | 178 / 210 (85% full) |
| Nursery Classes | Yes |
Ofsted Inspection Breakdown
23 Jan 2024Overall Effectiveness
Good
Additional Provisions
Source: Ofsted, 12 Mar 2024. Ratings: 1=Outstanding, 2=Good, 3=Requires Improvement, 4=Inadequate.
League Table Position
Based on KS2 Reading, Writing & Maths (32%)
13187th of 13,686
Nationally
1462nd of 1,506
In Yorkshire and the Humber
47th of 47
In York
Source: Classpot analysis of DfE KS2 Reading, Writing & Maths data
KS2 SATs Results
2023/24Reading, Writing & Maths Combined
32%
Expected Standard
3%
Higher Standard
'22/23
38%
'23/24
32%
Source: Department for Education, 2023/24. National expected standard benchmark is around 65%.
SEND Support
Source: Department for Education, 2024/25. Support availability based on current student population.
Facilities
8Facilities may vary. Contact the school for current availability.
Extracurriculars
9Sports
Clubs & Activities
Activities may vary by term. Contact the school for current offerings.
Admissions
2025/26Oversubscribed14
30
Good Demand
Popular school with more applications than places
12 families put this school as their 1st choice (40% of all applications)
Source: Department for Education, 2025/26. Data reflects national offer day applications and offers.
Class profile
2024/25Better than half of schools in England.
Better than 75% of schools in England.
Lower is generally better — fewer pupils per teacher or per class means more individual attention. Sources: DfE School Workforce Census & Schools, pupils and their characteristics, 2024/25.
Pupils & demographics
2024/25Above the national average (25%) — higher-disadvantage intake.
Above the national median (10%) — a meaningful share speak English as an additional language.
Ethnic background
- White British80.3%
- Asian8.9%
- White (other)5.6%
- Mixed2.8%
Source: DfE Schools, pupils and their characteristics (2024/25). Percentages may not sum to 100% — pupils classified as “unclassified”, “refused” or minor categories are not shown.
Attendance & Behaviour
2024/25Half of schools in England do better than this.
Better than half of schools in England.
Pupils missing 10% or more of sessions.
75% of schools in England do better than this.
A pupil temporarily sent home for behaviour.
Permanent exclusion is rare — most schools have none in a given year.
Ranks vs all state-funded schools in England. Source: DfE Pupil absence in schools & Suspensions and permanent exclusions.
Catchment & Local Competition
No catchment data published for this school
The dashed grey ring is a generic 1-mile reference area — it's not an admission boundary. Real catchment depends on year, demand, and council criteria. We currently have real data for about 6% of UK schools and are actively expanding the database.
⚠ This school is oversubscribed — without published cutoff data we can't show how far places reach. Check your council's admissions page.
Schools within 1 mile (reference area)
1 mile is a fixed reference, not this school's catchment.
8
Total schools
8
Oversubscribed
7
Primary
Don’t use the dashed grey ring as a catchment boundary — it’s a reference area for counting nearby schools only. Real admission boundaries depend on year-by-year demand and council criteria; ask the school or council for authoritative info.
Was this page helpful?
Frequently Asked Questions About St Aelred's Catholic Primary School - a Catholic Voluntary Academy
Helpful Guides for Parents
Ofsted Ratings Explained
Understand the 4 Ofsted ratings and what they mean
How to Choose a Primary School
Step-by-step guide to choosing the right primary school
KS2 SATs Explained
A parent's guide to Year 6 SATs and how results are reported
SEN & EHCP: A Parent's Guide
Understanding SEN support, EHC Plans and your legal rights
Contact Information
Fifth Avenue, York
York, YO31 0QQ
Journey to School
Journey times are estimates based on current conditions. Actual times may vary.
Opening Hours
Parent Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience at St Aelred's Catholic Primary School - a Catholic Voluntary Academy!
Write a Review